I think Sun Lu Tang wrote the first published book on Bagua in Chinese. He was certainly one of the great Masters of his time . His daughter was great also but not like her father..
The elbows should touch if possible when presenting the fruit in Monkey. I am convinced that posture protects the centerline of your body by interposing the touching forearms in front of the torso. It feels strange as your chest seems to invert but Snake can easily be done from the Monkey posture. ua-cam.com/video/ZRfyVluULY8/v-deo.html
Fabulous. This makes understanding his book on Pa Kua a little easier. On the best of days Pa Kua is difficult. Thank you for sharing that with us. We can use all the help we can get. Peace. Laoshr # 60 Ching Yi Kung Fu Association
I completely agree. All perform forms according to the pictures in the book. There are no direct explanations. It remains to be regretted that Sun Lutang's daughter did not leave educational videos and books on Sun Bagua.
Hey Andrew 👋 Great videos of Sun Lutang Bagua Zhang. I'm just getting started with Sun Style 73 I have a Spinal Disease I see how Bagua Helps. Wondering do you know online where I can find full tutorials of this Internal Art? Thanks again for posting great videos ☯️🙏
Hey Glee. Thank you for liking my videos. I have been practicing Baguazhang for 30 years. I'm 52 years old. Bagua is very helpful for the legs and spine. There are a lot of videos on Sun Lutang and other masters. Look at Luo Dexu. There are instructional videos on youtube. There are also translated books of Sun Lutang Baguazhang. Buy or download his book Baguaquanxue. Good luck!
@@Aklukva One observation I should make is the keeping of the hand in the exact middle of the circle as this guy is doing. I remember that phase, it seemed behaviorally unavoidable but unrealistic for fighting to my imagination. Eventually I passed through it.
@@Aklukva As If I were such, though I'm beginning to believe there is some group who pursue after them, leaving those unskilled alone. In chapter 12 of Sun Lu Tang's Bagua manual (Brennan trans.), in the description of the snake technique there is a mention of a book by Sun Lu Tang called Secrets of the Shaolin Boxing Art, published 1915. I've not been able to find a translation or copy of it anywhere. Let me know if you have one!
@@freestylebagua I agree. Lots of custom shapes. Interpretations. Regarding the book on the points attack, I don’t have it. I have lots chinese books on dian xue but not this one.
I think the foot work was a training for Xing Ie Dragon. You can bend your legs more and more taking fewer steps. Some people do splits around the circle. Walking on bricks makes stepping more of a challenge even more than posts of different heights. Walk in sand so you can see footsteps. Bring the foot up flat set down flat for crane step attack. Grip with your feet. Sit like a tiger walk like a dragon. 64 rules of performance.
I grew up practicing Silat and Escrima. I picked up Taiji, Bagua and Xingyi. I love making 8s and circles. Changed me in a great way. Much softer and way less aggressive. I was seriously aggressive before I went internal.
@@mikeneidlinger8857 Double Taiji Jian? That's Chen style, uh? Which Bagua style? But my question was more: what do you think of internal arts compared to what you did before?
I like practicing slow twisting and circling steps with blades. It nourishes my brain and I circulate my chi to stay healthy and massage my internal organs to stay soft and limber. The first thing I would teach someone is how to relax and root and circulate Qi. After relaxing,, someone can learn basic Gong Fu! I am trying to learn some Traditional Chinese Medicine right now.
すごい‼️奥が、深いですね‼️俺も、八卦掌を学んでいる、
@@user-vl3co4zp4e 最高のパフォーマンスではありません。
I think Sun Lu Tang wrote the first published book on Bagua in Chinese. He was certainly one of the great Masters of his time . His daughter was great also but not like her father..
very bad
this is the only correct Sun Lutang's form in the whole UA-cam.
No
Please Show combat intent by free styling. Thanks
I am a Taiji practitioner but I would like to learn at least the first two palm changes in The Circle.
Find the teacher. With real practical application of Bagua. Not the dance.
The elbows should touch if possible when presenting the fruit in Monkey. I am convinced that posture protects the centerline of your body by interposing the touching forearms in front of the torso. It feels strange as your chest seems to invert but Snake can easily be done from the Monkey posture. ua-cam.com/video/ZRfyVluULY8/v-deo.html
Fabulous Mastery! This is Real. All Respect.
如果你更喜歡, 我會停止問你問題 • 八卦掌界的其他人宣稱孫祿堂寫的關於八卦掌的論文書是為外人寫的 • 雖然我知道八卦掌都是出自同一個來源 (畢登霞、董海川), 但我真的很喜歡孫氏的方法並且願意去更深入地了解 • 儘管如此, 如果您願意, 我很樂意停止向您提問
再次你好克魯格師父: 我對許多,許多表示衷心的感謝您回覆我的問題和詢問的次數 • 你給了我很多時間 • 我學習武術三十五年了過去二十四年在內家拳 • 有沒有更深入研究孫氏八卦掌的書 (論文, 任何東西)嗎 「街上的傳言」(正如我們在美國所說的) 是, 孫祿堂所發表的論文比他教導他的室內弟子的系統細節相對較少 (這是可以理解的, 正常的, 常見的 典型的在這些嚴密保護的武術中藝術) •我知道這是一個不太可能的事情, 但是如果有任何書籍可以深入了解孫氏八卦掌, 請告訴我•另外, 如果您能告訴我有關老八掌 (其起源) 的任何信息, 我將不勝感激
你好，夏泉仙！ 你住在中国吗？ 你所在的城市有八卦掌流派或师父吗？
@@Aklukva 否 • 我不住在中國 • 我住在美國 •我已故的師父八年前去世了, 所以我一直在獨自經營 • 我來自程氏,高氏, 姜氏弟子 • 孫氏八卦掌是我必須透過書籍等才能獲得的東西, 並將我的程/高/江氏族的訓練融入其中 • 我的八卦掌基礎是原汁原味的套路姜容樵發展起來, 隨後出現了老八掌和游身鏈環八卦掌套路
你好克魯格師父: 有一種套路叫 "老八掌" • 你知道這種套路的起源嗎？程氏？殷族？董海川？
Hi Andrew, may I ask where you learn from? I'm from Hong Kong and i can't find any good master😭
Hi. I studied myself. You must be kidding that cant find the master in HK.
I studied myself too..I can't find any Sun style BaguaZhang master@@Aklukva
Much of what is presented in the videos is also a demonstration from the book. Much remains unclear.@@angus90ynh
這位是孫叔容前輩, 是孫祿堂公的孫女, 比孫劍雲前輩少四歲.
Хорошо и ясно показывает движения с фиксацией, спасибо.
Нет.
Very good example of a rare art.
Is this Sun Peng?
I don't know.
Excellent! Thank you!!
你好克魯格師父: 感謝您抽出時間來閱讀 這 • 有沒有後天 (即線性) 八卦掌長棍套路(嗎) -或- 六十四後天套路中任意武器套路(嗎)
你好. 不幸的是没有。
Very nice. This is how I was taught.
Fabulous. This makes understanding his book on Pa Kua a little easier. On the best of days Pa Kua is difficult. Thank you for sharing that with us. We can use all the help we can get. Peace. Laoshr # 60 Ching Yi Kung Fu Association
Enjoy!
At 1:12, awful. Like that would work. Hand needs to be extended away from the head. This is just the public simplified version of Sun's material.
I completely agree. All perform forms according to the pictures in the book. There are no direct explanations. It remains to be regretted that Sun Lutang's daughter did not leave educational videos and books on Sun Bagua.
@Aklukva the Indoor Style exists. Pictures are small guiding point. Sun stated "continuous movement" which is not seen here.
我向你致敬克陸格師公: 請原諒我的劣質中文並且 (很有可能) 把你的名字拼錯了• 感謝您分享這些視頻 • 好像是唯一練八卦通過 “動物” 來表達的家族是孫氏 (天堂=獅子, 地球=麒麟,水=蛇, 火=鷂, 雷=龍, 山=熊, 風=鳳凰, 霧=猴子) • 我沒有看到基本卦示為動物程氏, 殷氏, 高氏, 或者別的什麼地方 • 這很令人失望因為我真的很喜歡用動物表示的八卦 •有視頻顯示艮卦 “黑熊伸爪” 和離卦 “大蟒轉" 身卦的區別嗎?...和...坎卦的“白蛇藏草”和荀卦的“獅子伏地”? • “黑熊伸爪” 和 “大蟒蛇轉身” 長得很像和 “白蛇入草” 和 “獅子入地” 看起來很像 • 感謝您的時間和考慮
下午好 这么晚才回复很抱歉。 对于你的问题，我没有视频。 我们继续研究和破译孙氏八卦掌！
@@Aklukva 沒關係 : ) 感謝你的回复
Very good, most commenters clearly have no idea 😂
走样。The form totally deformed
同意
никудышнее исполнение: цветистые ручки, парчевые ножки а в сущности - ничего. Он хоть отдалённо имеет понятие что он делает?!
Hey Andrew 👋 Great videos of Sun Lutang Bagua Zhang. I'm just getting started with Sun Style 73 I have a Spinal Disease I see how Bagua Helps. Wondering do you know online where I can find full tutorials of this Internal Art? Thanks again for posting great videos ☯️🙏
I found some on here YT! 👍😁
Hey Glee. Thank you for liking my videos. I have been practicing Baguazhang for 30 years. I'm 52 years old. Bagua is very helpful for the legs and spine. There are a lot of videos on Sun Lutang and other masters. Look at Luo Dexu. There are instructional videos on youtube. There are also translated books of Sun Lutang Baguazhang. Buy or download his book Baguaquanxue. Good luck!
@@Aklukva Thank You so much 😁 I just checked out Master Luo Wow 😲 I have a pdf of Sun Lutang Study of Bagua. Keep Posting Great Videos 👍 Blessings 🙏
,👍🤗🤝
La forme nest pas complete quel dommage
En fait ce n'est pas Sun Shi Baguazhang.
@@Aklukva bonjour cette forma t elle un nom et peut on la retrouver en video ? Merci
Hélas
Can you fight xuxiaodong with this style?
Sure. But not this guy. He trains for health.
Xu sucks and so do the people he's fought so far
丰润曹雪芹公园，应该是邓师兄的学生。
More Sun Lutang! Not a lot out there.
不是一般的差。有辱八卦掌。
I don't know much but this man seems to hunch shoulders and has a hunched back... I love the music though! What is that track if I may ask?
Sorry, I don't know the name of the track.
你好克魯格師父: 優秀的套路示範 • 我學到的第一個八卦掌套路是姜容樵創造的 “原件”套路, 我學到的第二個套路是孫祿堂氏, 第三個學的是高義盛氏或程氏的 “八掌變形” (我不知道這兩氏族中的哪一個這個桃露來自); 顯然來自這兩種氏族風格之一 夏泉仙
上面这个是霍培林老师的视频。
@@hengchunma8854 非常感謝您的回复 • 我很感激 • 霍培林老師很好 • 江氏八卦掌我學得最多, 還有程氏和高氏 • 孫氏八卦掌我是通過教科書學的 夏泉仙
👍
Superb, who was that?
Sorry, I don't know.
@@Aklukva One observation I should make is the keeping of the hand in the exact middle of the circle as this guy is doing. I remember that phase, it seemed behaviorally unavoidable but unrealistic for fighting to my imagination. Eventually I passed through it.
@@freestylebagua 进了八卦门要终身走转不停.
@@Aklukva As If I were such, though I'm beginning to believe there is some group who pursue after them, leaving those unskilled alone. In chapter 12 of Sun Lu Tang's Bagua manual (Brennan trans.), in the description of the snake technique there is a mention of a book by Sun Lu Tang called Secrets of the Shaolin Boxing Art, published 1915. I've not been able to find a translation or copy of it anywhere. Let me know if you have one!
@@freestylebagua I agree. Lots of custom shapes. Interpretations. Regarding the book on the points attack, I don’t have it. I have lots chinese books on dian xue but not this one.
Xing but little yi.
张老兄是和程秉均老师学的，他和邓福明兄关系铁。练功的这个地方是唐山电厂附近的陡河边，后边是电厂的大烟囱。好几年没看到他了。
Wang Wang zhi
你好安德魯克魯格師傅: 很棒的演示! 謝謝你! 我最近讀了一些關於馬贵八卦掌的東西 • 一種走圈運動/圈走方法, 叫做“熊走”的馬步 • 我以前從未聽說過這個 • 你知道它是什麼以及如何去做(嗎) 非常感謝, 夏泉仙
夏泉仙, 好! 我看过《马贵八卦掌》这本书。 但我不知道熊走的马步法。有很多未知数！
@@Aklukva 我向你們致敬和我致以崇高的問候, 克魯格師傅 • 我也感謝您的回复; 我非常感激 • 我讀的是: "熊走-馬式" 慢速集中轉圈, 極大地改變了從脖子到肌(從領口到腳的肌腱)的大筋線, 增強了整個身體 • 這聽起來非同尋常; 我非常想學的東西 • 不過, 唉, 你是對的: 對於每一個已知都有一萬個未知數仍然存在 • 許多未知數
@@chuanxianxia 我同意。 除了继续学习，别无他法。
This one is most excellent, the flavor I've tasted in my mind but this is the first I've actually seen it.
I think the foot work was a training for Xing Ie Dragon. You can bend your legs more and more taking fewer steps. Some people do splits around the circle. Walking on bricks makes stepping more of a challenge even more than posts of different heights. Walk in sand so you can see footsteps. Bring the foot up flat set down flat for crane step attack. Grip with your feet. Sit like a tiger walk like a dragon. 64 rules of performance.
Where might I find the rest of this video?
Have no idea. Just found his performance in Youku.
I grew up practicing Silat and Escrima. I picked up Taiji, Bagua and Xingyi. I love making 8s and circles. Changed me in a great way. Much softer and way less aggressive. I was seriously aggressive before I went internal.
What do you think of internal arts?
I love to practice double Taiji Jian the most. Bagua is one I really like.
@@mikeneidlinger8857 Double Taiji Jian? That's Chen style, uh? Which Bagua style? But my question was more: what do you think of internal arts compared to what you did before?
I like practicing slow twisting and circling steps with blades. It nourishes my brain and I circulate my chi to stay healthy and massage my internal organs to stay soft and limber. The first thing I would teach someone is how to relax and root and circulate Qi. After relaxing,, someone can learn basic Gong Fu! I am trying to learn some Traditional Chinese Medicine right now.
这位老师傅练的好像孙振川前辈那支传下来的。
I like
Thanks.
Исполняет хорошо но большого мастерства ещё нет.
她只是練習套路,能夠記得住,已經很好了。美丽的樣子,悅耳的曲子,希望住在她家旁,每日看到她練習。 為什麼我只看到4式？
親愛的克魯格師父: 謝謝您分享這些精彩的八卦掌視頻 • 我們之前有過通信 • 我被猴子套路的套路弄糊塗了 • “猴抱桃” 套路是攻擊的預備姿勢(嗎) • 例如您如何向猴套路嗎 (即: 如果對這個主題一無所知的人要求你解釋猴子的套路嗎) • 非常感謝 夏泉仙
你好！ 新年快乐！ 我认为“猴抱桃”已经是一种攻击方式。 很多选择。 这是一个打和一个抓斗等等。 形式不是一个死板的模板，而是一个大致的轮廓。
@@Aklukva謝謝您克魯格師父 • 我非常感謝您的澄清 • 我應該在幾年前就此事與您聯繫, 哈哈 (笑聲) 夏泉仙
Well done!
古樸簡潔!一点花巧都沒有!古風尚傳!好拳法o
I wasn't counting, per se, but Snake Form is missing. 🐍 P.S.: Thanks for sharing. 😎👍
Yep. And btw not the best performance.